The distinction between internal voices and psychotic voices is clinically important, especially in trauma work, dissociation, and psychosis-spectrum conditions.
Below is a structured comparison from a psychological lens.
Internal Voices (Non-Psychotic)
These are usually understood as forms of inner experience, not hallucinations.
They may occur in:
- Normal inner speech (self-talk)
- High stress
- Trauma-related dissociation
- Parts-based personality structures (e.g., IFS-style parts)
- Grief
- Intense imagination
Characteristics
- Experienced as coming from inside the mind
- Recognized as “my thoughts” or “a part of me”
- Often dialogical (self arguing with self)
- Usually retain reality testing
- Can be influenced intentionally
- Person knows they are not external beings
Examples:
- “Part of me wants to leave, part of me wants to stay.”
- Hearing a deceased loved one’s voice internally but knowing they are not physically present.
- Critical self-talk with a tone or personality.
Neurocognitively, these relate to variations in inner speech generation and monitoring, often involving prefrontal–temporal circuits.
Psychotic Voices (Auditory Verbal Hallucinations)
These are typically associated with disorders like:
- Schizophrenia
- Schizoaffective disorder
- Bipolar disorder (with psychotic features)
- Severe major depression with psychosis
Characteristics
- Experienced as external (outside the head)
- Often perceived as autonomous entities
- Not recognized as self-generated
- May comment, command, or converse
- Frequently intrusive and uncontrollable
- Often accompanied by delusions
- Impaired reality testing
Examples:
- “The government is speaking to me through the wall.”
- Voices giving commands.
- Multiple distinct voices arguing about the person.
Neuroimaging studies suggest altered activity in speech perception areas (e.g., superior temporal gyrus) and impaired source monitoring.
“CONSULT WITH A NEUROLOGIST, and a PSYCHIATRIST”“
Trauma-Related Voices (The Gray Area)
This is where things get clinically nuanced.
In conditions like:
- Dissociative identity disorder
- Complex PTSD
- Severe developmental trauma
Voices may:
- Feel separate or “not me”
- Have distinct identities
- Represent dissociated self-states
- But still exist within a dissociative framework rather than primary psychosis
Key difference:
Reality testing is often largely intact, and the voices are psychologically meaningful (linked to trauma memory, internalized figures, attachment disruptions).
Core Differentiators
| Feature | Internal Voices | Psychotic Voices |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Inside mind | External space |
| Ownership | Recognized as self/part of self | Experienced as other |
| Reality testing | Intact | Impaired |
| Control | Some influence possible | Little to none |
| Associated symptoms | Dissociation, stress | Delusions, disorganization |
| Insight | Usually present | Often absent |
Important Clinical Note
Voice hearing alone does not equal psychosis.
Many non-psychotic individuals report voice-like experiences, especially:
- Trauma survivors
- Highly imaginative individuals
- Individuals under extreme stress
- People in bereavement
The key question is:
Is reality testing intact?
From a Depth Psychology Perspective
Internal voices can represent:
- Internalized parental objects
- Superego structures
- Dissociated ego states
- Unintegrated affective fragments
Psychotic voices tend to reflect:
- Breakdown in ego boundaries
- Failed source monitoring
- Projection of internal content into perceived external reality
- Shervan K Shahhian
LIBERTY PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION 